Understanding and implementing cost-cutting measures can make the difference
between thriving and merely surviving in the current economic climate.
By Kevin Krakora
The wine industry, with its blend of tradition and innovation, faces a unique set of challenges in today’s economic landscape. From unpredictable harvests to shifting consumer preferences, the need for effective cost management has never been more critical. Whether you’re a boutique vineyard or a larger operation, understanding and implementing cost-cutting measures can make the difference between thriving and merely surviving in the current economic climate.
Cost Cutting: Streamlining Storage and Shipping Fulfillment
One of the most significant (yet often taken-for-granted) expenses for wineries is storage and shipping fulfillment. Inventory management and order fulfillment are critical components for wineries, and yet many wineries are dramatically overpaying for inadequate services. Too many are merely content with or overly tolerant of their current providers, failing to realize the potential savings that shopping around could yield.
Several large companies in the industry offer bulk storage and shipping services. While it might seem like a headache to change partners and transfer massive quantities of cased wine, the long-term benefits can be substantial. Consider switching to more efficient providers that offer more responsive service, more detailed and useful reporting, and lower costs. The goal isn’t necessarily to find the cheapest option; it’s to find a partner that can enhance your operations while reducing expenses.
When evaluating fulfillment centers, consider factors beyond just price. Look at their track record for accuracy, their attitude towards compliance issues, their ability to handle peak seasons and their technology integration capabilities.
Take the opportunity to speak with their other winery customers to check on service levels, delivery history, responsiveness and reporting timeliness. A provider that can seamlessly connect with your inventory management and e-commerce systems can save you both time and money in the long run.
Cost Cutting: Optimizing Vineyard Management
Being an employer in the winery industry is no walk in the vineyard, particularly in California. California labor laws are the most complex in the country, and compliance can be costly. This is where strategic thinking about your workforce may lead to significant savings.
In many cases, outsourcing vineyard management can be more cost-effective than maintaining an in-house team. There are farming companies that specialize in providing skilled labor for vineyard operations.
By outsourcing, you can often reduce the hefty costs associated with full-time employees, including benefits, workers’ compensation, training and the administrative burden of compliance with California’s myriad labor regulations.
However, this isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution. You should base your decision to outsource on a careful analysis of your specific situation. Consider factors such as the size of your vineyard, the complexity of your operations, the cost of farming vehicles and equipment and your long-term business strategy.
In some cases, a hybrid model might be most effective. In this model, you maintain a core team of full-time employees and supplement it with outsourced labor during peak seasons. When maintaining a core team, investing in ongoing training and development for those workers is essential.
Cost Cutting: Navigating the Insurance Landscape
Insurance costs in the wine industry have skyrocketed, and in some cases, coverage has become nearly impossible to obtain. This is particularly true for vineyard fire insurance in regions prone to wildfires. Unfortunately, when it comes to insurance, wineries are often price takers rather than price makers. Sometimes, it feels like you’re practically begging for coverage, and if you get it, you’ll likely pay a massive premium.
While there’s no magic solution to this problem, you can take steps to potentially reduce your premiums or at least mitigate your risks. Implementing robust fire prevention measures is crucial when possible. This might include clearing out trees and brush around your property — though be aware that local regulations can sometimes restrict these activities.
Look for an insurance broker that specializes in the wine industry. They may have access to markets or programs that aren’t widely available and can help you structure your coverage to maximize protection while minimizing costs. Even then, expect a sizeable cost if you’re one of the lucky wineries that can secure a policy.
Revenue Generation: Leveraging Wine Libraries
Your wine library is more than just a showcase of your winery’s history. When used strategically, it can also be an important source of revenue. While some wineries hold onto library wines indefinitely, waiting for increased value over time, this strategy isn’t always the most profitable.
Instead, consider strategically releasing library vintages to your wine club members. This not only generates immediate revenue but also enhances the perceived value of your wine club membership. For example, you might offer a 10-year-old vintage or a unique vertical at a special price to club members, creating a sense of exclusivity and encouraging loyalty.
These library releases can be particularly effective when done off-cycle from your regular wine club shipments. It keeps members engaged throughout the year and can provide a welcome cash flow boost during typically slower periods.
Moreover, don’t overlook the potential of using your wine library as a financial asset. Some lenders will provide loans against the appraised value of your library. While this should be approached cautiously, it can be a valuable tool for accessing capital when needed.
Revenue Generation: Maximizing Direct-to-Consumer Sales
In the world of wine sales, direct-to-consumer (DTC) is king when it comes to margins. While wholesale channels have their place, particularly for larger producers, focusing on DTC sales can significantly boost your bottom line.
One effective strategy for driving DTC sales is developing relationships with local high-end hotels and lodgings. These establishments often cater to the exact demographic you want visiting your tasting room — individuals with disposable income who are looking for unique experiences. By providing these hotels with materials about your winery and perhaps offering special experiences for their guests, you can drive the right kind of traffic to your tasting room.
Remember, you’re not just selling wine; you’re selling an experience. The goal is to attract visitors who are likely to join your wine club, not just those looking for a quick tasting. A positive, elevated tasting room experience can translate into long-term customer relationships and consistent revenue through wine club memberships.
Social media and digital marketing are also crucial for maximizing DTC sales. Consistent, engaging content can keep your brand top-of-mind for consumers. Share behind-the-scenes glimpses of your winemaking process, highlight your beautiful vineyard views and create excitement around new releases.
Consider implementing a content calendar that aligns with your release schedule. For instance, have your winemaker share insights about an upcoming vintage in the weeks leading up to its release. This builds anticipation and can drive pre-orders and tasting room visits.
Every Dollar Counts
In an industry as challenging and competitive as wine, every dollar saved on expenses or gained through smart revenue strategies counts. By optimizing your storage and shipping, rethinking your approach to vineyard management, navigating the tricky waters of insurance, leveraging your wine library and focusing on high-margin DTC sales, you can improve your winery’s financial health without compromising on quality.
Keep in mind that implementing these strategies isn’t about cutting corners. It’s about being smarter with your resources so you can focus on what truly matters: crafting exceptional wines and creating memorable experiences for your customers. In the end, a financially healthy winery is better positioned to invest in quality, innovation and growth, ensuring a bright future for your brand in the ever-evolving world of wine.
__________________________________________________________________________________
Kevin A. Krakora, CTP, is a managing director at Getzler Henrich, with more than 30 years of experience in corporate turnarounds, strategic consulting and corporate restructurings. He recently served as chief restructuring officer of Spring Mountain Vineyard. Contact him at kkrakora@getzlerhenrich.com or (312) 283-8071.
